The evolution of quilts from the norm of mummy bags was a highly effective design that came from very sound engineering. However, the execution of the idea, over time, has exposed gross incompetence amongst manufacturers and resulted in reactive polarization amongst public opinion.
For the most part, quilts are manufactured in the most basic, home-built level, sophistication. The designs favor ultra cheap production and rely on hype to generate sales. Very little has been done to cope with the inherent issues that arise from new designs. For quilts it is drafts. It is not that quilt drafts are an insurmountable engineering obstacle. It’s simply that nobody is addressing it well.
So the result is that quilts just get wider and heavier, because that is the only mechanism to deal with drafts, in the absence of built-in solutions. By this point, the oversized quilt has reached the weight of well-designed mummy bags. This is absolutely not because they are on even ground in terms of insulation efficiency, by any means. Mummy bags, with bottom side insulation, are incredibly inefficient and antiquated for most use cases. Sure, they can work fine. Just not ever in a weight efficient manner. If drafts are handled, an equivalent quilt or false bottom bag will always beat it by significant margins.
Unfortunately, the public’s tendency is to polarize around issues like this. If they used a drafty quilt, the reaction is to determine that quilts don’t work and going back to a mummy bag is the solution. That is going from one extreme end of a spectrum and deciding the solution is the complete opposite. It’s like deciding that a horse and carriage is the solution to your car window not rolling up. This is somewhat understandable, since it’s manufacturers that are supposed to be engineering performant products. The perspective of the public is limited to what manufacturers make available.
We haven’t really even scratched the surface of what quilts can do and we’re really ignoring all the possibilities between quilts and mummy bags. We’re supposed to take what we learn from mistakes and apply it to forward motion. Not regress towards antiquated ideas when there are clear advantages that just need a little engineering to polish up.